Building the City: Urban Transition and Institutional Frictions

November 27 2017

We model a growing city and calibrate the model with data on Nairobi, focusing on investment decisions and the evolution of the built environment over time and space. We distinguish between formal and informal (slum) construction. The former can be built tall, but structures once built are durable and cannot be modified without complete demolition. In contrast, slum structures are malleable and do not incur sunk costs. As the city grows, areas will initially be developed informally and then formally; formal areas are redeveloped periodically. This process can be hindered by formalisation costs of converting slum to formal sector usage which vary by a location and result in a hotchpotch of developments. In the empirics, we analyse Nairobi for 2003 and 2015 using unique data. We develop a novel set of facts about the evolution of the built environment and calibrate the model. Built volume in the core part of the city increases by 50-60% over 12 years driven by increased height of redeveloped buildings. We calculate the welfare cost of delayed formalisation. We find that, in the older slums nearer the city centre, even after paying slumlords for the value of their land in perpetual slum use, formalisation would bring a gain of about $16-17,000 per slum household, in a context where slum households spend about $600-700 a year on housing.

Download - Working Paper

Authors

Tony Venables is Professor of Economics at the University of Oxford where he also directs the Centre for the Analysis of Resource Rich Economies. He has published extensively in the areas of international trade and spatial economics, including work on trade and imperfect competition, economic integration, multinational firms, and economic geography.

Vernon Henderson joined the LSE in September 2013 as School Professor of Economic Geography, having previously been Eastman Professor of Political Economy at Brown University, USA.

Tanner Regan is a PhD student at the London School of Economics and works in the Urban and Spatial Programme at the Centre for Economic Performance. He is broadly interested in urban, spatial, and development economics with a current focus is on the role of slums in shaping the built environment of African cities. He has ongoing work with the Urbanisation in Developing Countries Programme based at LSE and Oxford.